Every episode of You Can't Ask That features individuals who sit in front of a camera and candidly answer questions submitted by an anonymous public. Looking directly down the camera lens, the answers may be funny, serious or sad, but they are delivered honestly and candidly.

Season two participants include:

Oliver Sansom
Curtis Ruttle
Saoud Messaoudi
Owen Iahnijah Kane Babajide Opaleke
Kaleb-Wolf De Melo Torres
Maria Bangash
Nicola "Nikki" Joy Schmidt
Ella Van Enter

Donna Riguidel
Alain Guimond
Jason Helmond
Jillian Brown
Terrance Joseph Kosikar
Louis “Lou” Savard
Jamie MacWhirter
Michelle Spiteri
Michael Akpata

Yat Li 
Juan Jaramillo
Carlisle Robinson 
Ryan Parkinson
Laura Campbell
Melissa Mckee
Natasha Bacchus
Natasha Luttrell

Emiliana Calderon-Donefer 
Linda Monteith Gardiner 
Tracey Kosowan
Ilyas Khamis
Adrianne Roberts 
Matt Pattillo Roberts
Jesse Bigelow
Ketan Jung Dulal

Frank Pagnelli 
Marie Pontini
Armen Mamourian
Simraj Ubhi
Paige Christian
Danielle Ritchot-Sopko
Marielle Javate

Onika Dainty 
Andrea Paquette 
Shawntay Rose Dann
Scarlet Redpath
Victoria Maxwell
Chris Nihmey
Audley G. Coley
Jason W. Finucan 

Hubert Bourque 
Cory Narbonne 
Kim Petrie 
Nadia Tagliabracci 
Timothy Max Hague
Linda Bérard
Jeannine Alain
Glenn Hogan

Hannah Macintyre
Wade Sorochan
Kendra Fisher
Arthur Gallant
Stacy-Ann Buchanan
Arlene Porritt
Shannon Nagy
Dwyane Tuck